Property Law Developments—Joseph William Singer

An Alabama judge refused to allow a trustee to foreclose on a mortgage that had been made part of a securitized package of loans because there was no signed endorsement on the note (the contract creating the original loan) when the mortgage was transferred to the trust that held the securitized mortgages. Because the parties did not strictly adhere to the writing requirement in the state version of the UCC (Uniform Commercial Code) — a particularized version of the statute of frauds — the transfer of the mortgage never occurred and the trustee has no power to foreclose. Nor did the trustee have the rights of a “holder” of the note under the UCC because it did not acquire the note in a manner that complied with the rules in its foundational documents. In effect the party bringing the foreclosure action could not show that it had acquired the right to foreclose through properly executed documents evidencing the transfers of the mortgage from the original lender down the chain of title. see article