Below are blog posts, articles and essays I’ve written toward four goals in fighting surveillance of our private spaces online by the tracking-based advertising business and its dependents in publishing and other online services. Those are,
- To replace tracking-based advertising (aka adtech) with advertising that sponsors journalism, doesn’t frack our heads for the oil of personal data, and respects personal freedom and agency.
- To goad journalists toward grabbing the third rail of their own publications’ participation in what Shoshana Zuboff calls surveillance capitalism (adtech being a prime example). Perpetrators include nearly every name-brand news purveyor on the Web, including The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Guardian, The Atlantic, The New Yorker, and The Washington Post. (Links from @acfou‘s PageXray.) Get this straight: these pubs are no less guilty of spying on their readers than are the tech giants which the same publications are glad (and correct) to examine and shame—and are participating far less obviously. (To see how guilty they are, run any of the tracking protection browser add-ons listed here, or run PageXray, above.)
- To encourage research toward fully understanding what adtech is and does, plus guidance toward better business models for publishers.
- To help guide business and government toward respecting both personal privacy and personal agency in the digital world. Alas, the GDPR and the CCPA have done too little, so far, to halt surveillance by adtech—and almost nothing to advance personal agency. If the GDPR alone had done its job, GDPR compliance wouldn’t be an industry primarily composed of outsourced suppliers providing ways to obey the law’s letter while screwing its spirit. To see how big that industry is, go to that last link.)
It should help to know that all the advertising you ever saw in non-digital media—the kind that created nearly every worldwide brand you can name—still works fine. It also requires minimal cognitive and operational overhead and actually supports both advertisers and media. (For more on that, read Separating Advertising’s Wheat and Chaff.)
- Permission Slip, a Consumer Reports Privacy App (a 9 February 2019 podcast on Reality 2.0)
- The most important standard in development today (11 October 2022)
- Attention is Not a Commodity (18 September 2022)
- The Empire Strikes On (31 July 2022)
- Customer-Centric Marketing With Doc Searls (21 July 2021)
- Toward a lexicon for advertising in both directions (9 June 2022 in ProjectVRM)
- Apple + (or vs) Adtech Part II (30 May2021)
- Apple + (or vs) Adtech Part I (29 May 2021)
- How the cookie poisoned the Web (14 May 2021)
- A New Way (5 May 2021 in ProjectVRM and Customer Commons)
- Thinking outside the browser (21 March 2021 in ProjectVRM and Customer Commons)
- Why is the “un-carrier” falling into the hellhole of tracking-based advertising? (11 March 2021)
- Just in case you feel safe with Twitter (26 January 2021)
- Bet on obsolescence (23 August 2020)
- Time for advertising to call off the dogs (4 August 2020)
- So far, privacy isn’t a debate (22 June 2020)
- The best way to forget is to never know (9 June 2020)
- What if we called cookies “worms”? (26 May 2018 in ProjectVRM)
- Saving the Internet—and All the Commons It Makes Possible (20 February 2020). This is the print version of my Ostrom Memorial Lecture, given on 9 October 2019 at the Ostrom Workshop at Indiana University. The video is here and my part begins 11 minutes in.)
- Do you really need all this personal information, @RollingStone? (22 January 2020)
- On Privacy Fundamentalism (3 September 2019 in ProjectVRM)
- There are better ways to save journalism (1 September 2019)
- Privacy Manifesto, in continuing draft at the ProjectVRM wiki, it was also duplicated experimentally on 6 July 2019 at Medium)
- Dear @WashingtonPost (28 June 2019)
- The Wurst of the Web (23 March 2019 in ProjectVRM)
- *Is ad blocking past 2 billion worldwide? (23 March 2019)
- The Spinner’s hack on journalism (27 February 2019)
- A citizen-sovereign way to pay for news—or for any creative work (11 February 2019, enlarged on 15 February)
- If your privacy is the hands of others alone, you don’t have any (16 December 2018 in Privacy News Online and 9 January 2019 in Linux Journal)
- Privacy as a Right (5 December 2018 in Privacy News Online)
- Privacy is Personal (30 November 2018 in Privacy News Online)
- Is this a turning point for publishing? (24 October 2018)
- Toward no longer running naked in the virtual world (12 October 2018)
- Engineers vs. Re-Engineering (2 August 2018 in Linux Journal)
- Privacy = personal agency + respect by others for personal dignity (10 July 2018 in ProjectVRM)
- Without enforcement, the GDPR is a fail (3 July 2018)
- Why personal agency matters more than personal data (and in Medium on 23 June 2018)
- Let’s solve the deeper problem that makes Facebook’s bad acting possible (8 June 2018 in Linux Journal)
- What’s wrong with bots is they’re not our own (7 June 2018)
- A Brand Advertising Restoration Project (31 May 2018 in Linux Journal)
- Wanted: Online Pubs Doing Real (and therefore GDPR-compliant) Advertising (30 May 2018)
- An FUQ for the GDPR (24 May 2018 in Linux Journal)
- Cookies that go the other way (21 May 2018)
- Let’s Make May 25th Privmas Day (16 May 2018)
- Our time has come (16 May 2018 in ProjectVRM)
- GDPR will pop the adtech bubble (12 May 2018)
- Privacy is still personal (4 May 2018 in Linux Journal)
- Privacy is personal. Let’s start there. (2 May 2018 in Customer Commons and in Medium)
- How wizards and muggles break free from The Matrix (4 April 2018 in Linux Journal)
- For privacy we need tech more than policy (2 April 2018)
- Facebook’s Cambridge Analytica problems are nothing compared to what’s coming for all of online publishing (23 March 2018)
- Help Us Cure Online Publishing of Its Addiction to Personal Data (14 March 2018 in Linux Journal)
- What’s the Geek Take on the GDPR? (12 March in Linux Journal)
- Every User a Neo (31 January 2018 in Linux Journal)
- Facebook’s Fatal Flaws (4 January 2018 in Medium)
- An easy fix for a broken advertising system (12 October 2017 in Medium and in my blog)
- Without aligning incentives, we can’t kill fake news or save journalism (15 September 2017 in Medium)
- Let’s get some things straight about publishing and advertising (9 September 2017 and the same day in Medium)
- We need customertech. Simple as that. (4 September 2017 in Medium. It’s also an answer to a comment under “Markets are more than marketing,” below.)
- Good news for publishers and advertisers fearing the GDPR (3 September 2017 in ProjectVRM and 7 October in Medium).
- Markets are about customers, not marketing or advertising. (2 September 2017 in Medium).
- How the personal data extraction industry ends (27 August 2017 and 28 August 2017 in Medium).
- Publishers’ and advertisers’ rights end at a browser’s front door (17 June 2017 in Medium). It updates one of the 2015 blog posts below.
- Google enters its chrysalis (16 June 2017 and on the same date in Medium).
- Actual chat with an Internet disservice provider (12 June 2017 in Medium). Relevant because it uses technical relatives of adtech to make humans sound like robots and vice versa.
- How to plug the publishing revenue drain (9 June 2017 in Medium). It expands on the opening (#publishing) section of my Daily Tab for that date.
- Customertech Will Turn the Online Marketplace Into a Marvel-Like Universe in Which All of Us are Enhanced (29 May 2017 at ProjectVRM and in Medium)
- CustomerTech (15 May 2017 at ProjectVRM)
- When the customer becomes the first party (a talk given on 9 May 2017 at the European Identity and Cloud conference in Munich)
- The question is whether we’ll kill all of advertising or just some of it (6 May 2017 in Medium).
- Our radical hack on the whole marketplace (30 April 2017 in ProjectVRM)
- What if businesses agreed to customers’ terms and conditions? (28 April 2017)
- How are ad blockers affecting journalism? (My answer to a Quora question on 27 April 2017)
- The only way customers come first (26 April 2017 in Customer Commons)
- Brands need to fire adtech (23 March, and 25 March in Medium)
- The Problem with Content (1 March 2017 in Linux Journal)
- The Next Revolution in Advertising Will Be One Customers Lead (7 February 2017 in Medium)
- How True Advertising Can Save Journalism From Drowning in a Sea of Content (22 January 2017 in Medium and 26 January 2017 in my blog.)
- How adtech, not ad blocking, breaks the social contract (31 December 2016 in Medium)
- After Peak Marketing (3 December 2016 in Medium)
- How tools for customers have more leverage than tools for business alone (16 November 2016 in Medium).
- The egg on Zuck’s face. (12 November 2016) and That’s not fake egg on Zuck’s face (24 November in Medium). The latter improves on the former.
- Marketing bullshit is a structural problem. (28 October 2016 in Doc.Blog) Nice follow from Don Marti at Aloodo.
- The problem for people isn’t advertising, and the problem for advertising isn’t blocking. The problem for both is tracking.(21 October 2016 and same date in Medium).
- Market intelligence that flows both ways (27 August 2016 in Medium. It updates a 2014 blog post.)
- It’s People vs. Advertising, not Publishers vs. Adblockers (26 August 2016 in ProjectVRM and 27 August 2016 in Medium)
- The cash model of customer experience (17 August 2016 and 18 August 2016 in Medium).
- If it weren’t for retargeting, we might not have adblocking (13 August 2016 in ProjectVRM and 15 August 2016 in Medium)
- Nobody else owns our experiences (3 August 2016 and 1 October 2017 in Medium).
- The Castle Doctrine (19 June 2016 in ProjectVRM, and in Medium)
- Why #NoStalking is a good deal for publishers (11 May 2016, and in Medium)
- Is the advertising bubble finally starting to pop? (9 May 2016, and in Medium)
- How customers can debug business with one line of code (19 April 2016 in ProjectVRM and in Medium)
- An invitation to settle matters with @Forbes, @Wired and other publishers (15 April 2016 and in Medium)
- TV Viewers to Madison Avenue: Please quit driving drunk on digital (14 Aprl 2016, and in Medium)
- For true true two-way agreements with websites and services, we need terms we can assert and they can accept. (9 April 2016 in Medium)
- The Data Bubble Redux (9 April 2016)
- A Way Off the Ranch (1 April 2016 in Medium)
- Time for THEM to agree to OUR terms (29 March 2016 in Customer Commons and in Medium)
- Giving Customers Scale (15 March 2016 in Medium, expanding on an earlier post in Customer Commons)
- Earth to marketing: customers don’t want to be “acquired” (14 March 2016 in ProjectVRM)
- @BlockstackOrg, @IPFS, @OpenBazaar, @OneName, @Telehash, @Mine_Labs #Mediachain, @IBMIVB #ADEPT: Come 2 @IDworkshop and @VRM Day (28 February in ProjectVRM) This was later retitled and partially rewritten as Iot & IoM next week at IIW (20 April 2016)
- What if we don’t need advertising at all? (15 February 2016 in ProjectVRM) Also in Medium (Same date.)
- Is Adblock good for customers? (4 February 2016 in Quora)
- Rethinking John Wanamaker (18 January 2016)
- What we can do with ad blocking’s leverage (1 January 2016 in Linux Journal)
- Why ad blocking is good (17 December 2015 talk at the U. of Michigan)
- More thoughts on privacy (13 December 2015)
- The End of Internet Advertising as We’ve Known It (11 December 2015 in MIT Technology Review, and also 1 January 2016 on Audible)
- At last, Cluetrain’s time has come (5 December 2015)
- Ad Blockers and the Next Chapter of the Internet (5 November in Harvard Business Review)
- How Will the Big Data Craze Play Out (1 November 2015 in Linux Journal)
- How #adblocking matures from #NoAds to #SafeAds (22 October 2015)
- Helping publishers and advertisers move past the ad blockade (11 October on the ProjectVRM blog)
- Dealing with Boundary Issues (1 October 2015 in Linux Journal)
- The biggest boycott in world history (28 Septemper 2015)
- A way to peace in the adblock war (21 September 2015, on the ProjectVRM blog)
- How adtech, not ad blocking, breaks the social contract (23 September 2015)
- Debugging adtext assumptions (18 September 2015)
- If marketing listened to markets, they’d hear what ad blocking is telling them (8 September 2015)
- Will content blocking push Apple into advertising’s wheat business? (29 August 2015)
- Apple’s content blocking is chemo for the cancer of adtech (26 August 2015)
- Separating advertising’s wheat and chaff (12 August 2015, and on 2 July 2016 in an updated version in Medium)
- Captivity rules (29 March 2015)
- On taking personalized ads personally (27 March 2015)
- Because freedom matters (26 March 2015)
- Thoughts on tracking based advertising (18 February 2015)
- On marketing’s terminal addiction to data fracking and bad guesswork (10 January 2015)
- We’re all going to need clothes (18 December 2014)
- Privacy is personal (2 July 2014 in Linux Journal)
- Time for digital emancipation (27 July 2014)
- Why to avoid advertising as a business model (25 June 2014, re-running Open Letter to Meg Whitman, which ran on 15 October 2000 in my old blog)
- Earth to Mozilla: Come back home (12 April 2014)
- We are not fish and advertising is not food (23 January 2014 in Customer Commons)
- Beyond the advertising bubble (12 October 2013 in Customer Commons)
- What the ad biz needs is to exorcize direct marketing (6 October 2013)
- Thoughts on Privacy (31 August 2013)
- Bringing manners to marketing (12 January 2013 in Customer Commons)
- What could/should advertising look like in 2020, and what do we need to do now for this future? (Wharton’s Future of Advertising project, 13 November 2012)
- Browsers should have been cars. Instead they’re shopping carts. (22 September 2012)
- An olive branch to advertising (12 September 2012, on the ProjectVRM blog)
- Inkwell: Authors and Artists -Topic 451: Doc Searls, The Intention Economy, an online conversation in The Well (15-21 August 2012)
- After Facebook Fails (23 May 2012)
- Stop making cows. Quit being calves. (21 February 2012)
- For personal data, use value beats sale value (13 February 2012)
- A sense of bewronging (2 April 2011)
- The Data Bubble II (30 October 2010)
- The Data Bubble (31 July 2010)
- After the advertising bubble bursts (23 March 2009)
- Why online advertising sucks, and is a bubble (31 October 2008)
- The Because Effect and the Demise of Advertising. P2P Foundation (17 September 2008, and excerpted from Toward a New Ecology of Journalism, posted on 12 September 2007)
Pingback from Doc Searls Weblog · Bag ‘o tabs on February 14, 2016 at 10:55 am
These could almost be collected into a book of essays titled the same way this post is “The Adblock Wars.”
Perhaps a PDF with all these collected, at minimum (links included). But even a paperback would be nice (self-published).
Nice! These could almost be collected into a book of essays titled the same way this post is “The Adblock Wars.”
Pingback from Let’s talk advertising – DNN NEWS on January 15, 2018 at 3:12 pm
The issue our industry faces with ad tech is a considerable measure like the issue with gun control. gun control are extraordinary instruments. They are exceptionally helpful in the event that you need to shoot a deer or ensure your home. In any case, with no directions and a mess of terrible folks out there who might overlook them regardless of whether they existed we end up with a circumstance where weapons are all over the place, from the hands of the ultra-dependable to the hazardously messy to the out and out criminal.
Predicted a long time ago. I am commenting with a browser that blocks advertisements by default. Soon everyone will catch on.
Pingback from Doc Searls Weblog · About face on October 31, 2019 at 7:28 am
Pingback from Doc Searls Weblog · The eventual normal on March 11, 2021 at 11:37 am
Latest world news, breaking news and today’s news stories updated daily from the News team.
Stories Cover : https://storiescover.com/
Thanks so much for sharing ur blog, you can view my blog too for help me design my blog MYPEKAN BLOGGER
this is amazing, this article is really amazing and helps anyone with the imagination to create a blog, thank you for sharing with us and don’t forget to visit too and give input on the blog that I have at
I hope this message finds you well. I wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude for the incredibly helpful article that you have shared. Your insights and knowledge on the subject have been enlightening and informative, leaving me with a sense of gratitude for the valuable information you have provided.
In a world where technology evolves at an astonishing pace, staying updated with the latest news and advancements can be quite a challenge. Therefore, I would like to take this opportunity to introduce you to our website, where you can find a treasure trove of resources to satisfy your appetite for technology news.
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link: https://blogs.harvard.edu/doc/the-adblock-war/trackback/