Government “Bird Dogs” on the Loose in Saudi Arabia

In clashes between Saudi citizens and the state over ideology and technology, Twitter has become a highly contested space. Internet monitoring and censorship in the Kingdom is not new though. According to a 2009 report from the Open Net Initiative, “Saudi Arabia filters sites related to opposition political groups, human rights issues, and religious content deemed offensive to Muslims.” Freedom House published a report in 2012 putting Internet penetration in Saudi’s population of 29 million at 49%. It also stated that 51% of Saudis are active Twitter users, one of the highest usage rates in the world. In recent months, religious and political leaders as well as everyday Twitter users have taken to the ethereal skies of Twitter to express their views on how and by whom the social networking site should be used.

It is easy to adopt ornithological metaphors when talking about Twitter, and we can extend talk of birds in a particular way within the Arab Gulf context, where falconry  is a big deal. The sport has ancient roots and great cultural significance. Falcons are magnificent birds of prey, revered and respected in the region for their adaptability, speed, and hunting prowess. The birds, also called raptors, scan the desert sands for prey and swoop in for the kill with pinpoint accuracy. In the Arab Gulf, the falcon is elegance, beauty, and skill with wings.

“Sporting with the best: Hamad AlGhanem, Director, Breeder and Registrar General of the Arabian Saluki Centre, poses with a falcon and two of his favourite salukis. Falconry and saluki races are a part of Arab culture.”- Gulf News

The same regal attributes may or may not apply, however, to the little blue birds that soar in the Twittersphere. Saudi authorities, acting like government bird dogs, have been on the hunt for Twitter users lately.

In early May, Saudi religious police issued warnings that the social networking site was “a path to hell.”  Sheikh Abdul Latif Abdul Aziz al-Sheikh said Muslims who use Twitter have “lost this world and [their] afterlife.” Despite this warning, Saudis—including religious leaders—continue to use the platform. Just weeks after al-Sheikh’s pronouncement, Abdullah Mohammed al-Dawood, an ultraconservative cleric with an active Twitter following, used Twitter to post his views on women going to work in Saudi Arabia. His tweet encouraged men to “harass” women working in public places, so they would return to their homes. Public outrage in response to al-Dawood’s comment was swift and decidedly critical. Graphic suggestions about what punishment he deserved, including castration, circulated in local social media—including Twitter, where the hashtag “#arm_female_cashiers” was used in reaction to al-Dawood’s call to “#harass_female_cashiers”—and spread globally via major news sources.

Despite threats to body and soul, Saudi citizens, journalists and activists continue to retweet rather than retreat. In fact, according to a recent poll about people’s attitudes toward information sharing on the Internet, Saudis are among the most willing to share “everything.” This is not exactly divine revelation to progressive Saudi thinkers and leaders such as Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, who addressed Saudi Telecommunications directly from his Twitter account: trying to block social media platforms is a “losing war.”


This entry was posted in Saudi Arabia, Social Media by Leigh Llewellyn Graham. Bookmark the permalink.

About Leigh Llewellyn Graham

Leigh is a Ph.D. candidate in anthropology at Columbia University and currently an intern at Harvard's Berkman Center for Internet and Society. Her work examines questions of citizenship, cultural learning practices, and digital division of labor in the 21st century knowledge economy. Overarching questions about human-machine relationships push her work into the realms of cyborgization studies, ethnophysiology, and the politics of women’s bodies.

4 thoughts on “Government “Bird Dogs” on the Loose in Saudi Arabia

  1. Wonderful blog especially highlighting the monitoring, but the continued use of social media in the Kingdom. Social media and the internet has opened a whole new world in the Middle East to give a voice to a generation that is looking for positive reforms in reforming their society. Thank you Leigh.

  2. Such a great piece, Leigh. Great job.

    Puts into relevant, social perspective an issue that many women in those environments battle with: the very platform that’s meant to be your vehicle of freedom, self-expression and liberation, being used to counteract those intentions and bully them further into submission. When tradition is challenged it’s always a matter of time to anticipate the push back…and the only thing you’re left with is how will I barrel through this obstacle.

    But the wonderful revelation it also brings to past is the resiliency that exists in all underrepresented and disregarded groups of people. And the ability to always seek out and utilize all resources to not only challenge what’s been a formidable, crippling force…but to also engage others in discourse that may seem irrelevant to their own social goings-on, but really does have an effect on all women and our progression as a unit–and to society. And these women offer so much by way of strength by any means necessary!

    Wouldn’t it be cool if there was a “ReTweet” don’t “Retreat” movement?! With t-shirts made of the little blue Twitter bird with the words Retreat written on it, sitting in one of those anti-, red circles with the slash going through it….

  3. Thanks for sharing the link to your blog post, and congratulations on the first of what will be many more postings. Liked the extended ornithological metaphor. There is a certain irony, however, in our preoccupation with the crude efforts of the Saudi conservative establishment to limit freedoms of expression in light of the revelations about the massive scale of the NSA’s surveillance of internet communications of American citizens. If Saudi clerics are behaving like “bird dogs”, a pack of wolves seems like the right metaphor to describe how the US government is behaving!

  4. Pingback: Flying Past Filters and Firewalls: Pigeons as Circumvention Tools | Political Query

Comments are closed.